Skip to main content
eXtremeRate ThumbsGear Interchangeable Ergonomic Thumbstick for PS5 Controller, for PS4 All Model Controller - 3 Height Domed and Concave Grips Adjustable Joystick - Black
eXtremeRate

eXtremeRate ThumbsGear Interchangeable Ergonomic Thumbstick for PS5 Controller

Bottom line: The eXtremeRate ThumbsGear Interchangeable Ergonomic Thumbstick: 6-in-1 kit: 3 stick heights x 2 grip surfaces = 8 usable combinations; main trade-off: PS5 and PS4 controllers only, no Xbox or Switch support.

Check price on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, SpecPicks earns from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure →

Check price on Amazon → Compare to similar controllers & gamepads

By , Founder & Editor-in-Chief · Listing data updated

Mike Perry — Hardware researcher since 2014. For PC and console controllers, synthesises manufacturer specs and independent reviews rather than first-hand lab testing. Core beat: GPU performance across gaming, rendering, and local-LLM inference.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • ✓ 6-in-1 kit: 3 stick heights x 2 grip surfaces = 8 usable combinations
  • ✓ Height swaps after base install need no controller teardown
  • ✓ Concave cap grips the thumb for precision aiming
  • ✓ Domed convex cap cuts thumb fatigue on long sessions
  • ✓ Screwdriver and prying tools included in the box

Cons

  • ✗ PS5 and PS4 controllers only, no Xbox or Switch support
  • ✗ Requires opening the controller shell for the initial base install
  • ✗ Opening the shell may affect controller warranty coverage
  • ✗ Plastic construction, not aluminum or rubberized caps

Manufacturer description

The eXtremeRate ThumbsGear interchangeable thumbstick set replaces the fixed analog sticks on your PS5 controller and all PS4 controller models with a 6-in-1 modular system. You get three stick heights and two grip surfaces, so you can mix and match eight combinations to suit whatever you're playing. The concave cap locks your thumb into the stick for precision aiming in shooters, while the domed convex cap spreads contact across a wider surface to reduce thumb fatigue during long sessions. Once the base is installed, swapping heights takes seconds and does not require taking the controller…

Related Products

Other products in this category you may like:

SpecPicks Verdict

SpecPicks scored eXtremeRate ThumbsGear Interchangeable Ergonomic Thumbstick using a rating × review-volume × price-fit model applied to published specs and reviews across the controllers & gamepads category. eXtremeRate's controllers & gamepads lineup sits within the broader category mid-tier; price and specs are the deciding factors over brand loyalty here. Judge it on the specification table and the price rather than on sentiment: check the figures that decide your use case, then put it side-by-side with two or three close alternatives in the Compare tool before clicking through.

Common buyer scenarios for controllers & gamepads of this kind: matching it to an existing build, replacing a failing part, or upgrading from a previous-generation equivalent. Check the spec table below against your current setup — particularly socket / form-factor / power-rating fields — and confirm compatibility on the retailer's listing before purchase. Prices and stock are set by the retailer and may have moved since this page was last updated.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will these fit my PS5 DualSense controller?

Yes. The ThumbsGear set fits the PS5 controller and all PS4 controller models. It does not fit Xbox, Switch, or other third-party controllers.

Do I have to open my controller to change the height?

Only once. You open the shell to install the base, then switch between the 3 heights freely without taking the controller apart again.

What is the difference between the concave and domed grips?

The concave surface lets your thumb sit tightly in the stick for better grip and control. The domed convex surface increases comfort and reduces hand and thumb fatigue.

Do I need my own tools to install this?

No. The kit includes a screwdriver and prying tools. eXtremeRate also posts an install guide on YouTube under video ID GJfxPgLN7_M.

Is this worth it over stock PlayStation thumbsticks?

The draw is the 8 height-and-grip combinations stock sticks cannot match.

Key Features

  • Compatibility: Compatible with PS5 controller, for PS4 all model controllers, NOT fit for other controllers
  • The 6 in 1 adjustable plastic analog joystick has 3 different heights. After installing the base, you can choose and switch your favorite height without having to take apart the controller every time
  • 2 different ergonomic thumb grip design. The concave surface can allow your fingers to fit tightly with the joystick for better grip; the convex surface can increase your comfort and reduce the fatigue of your hands and thumbs
  • Mix and match your thumbsticks from 3 different height and 2 different grips to fix different games
  • Easy to replace. the screwdriver and prying tools can help you easily open the shell and install the replacement part. Get the installation guide by searching “eXtremeRate ThumbsGear interchangeable thumbsticks for PS4” and “GJfxPgLN7_M” on Youtube

Full Specifications

BrandeXtremeRate
ColorBlack
Model NumberP4J1101
CompatibilityCompatible with PS5 controller, for PS4 all model controllers, NOT fit for other controllers
Mfr Part NumberP4J1101
Compatible DevicesPS5 Controller, PS4 Controller
Enclosure MaterialHard ABS plastic, TPU
Item Dimensions L x W x H1.97"L x 1.97"W x 0.59"H
Full listing titleeXtremeRate ThumbsGear Interchangeable Ergonomic Thumbstick for PS5 Controller, for PS4 All Model Controller - 3 Height Domed and Concave Grips Adjustable Joystick - Black

Ready to buy?

eXtremeRate ThumbsGear Interchangeable Ergonomic Thumbstick for PS5 Controller, for PS4 All Model Controller - 3 Height Domed and Concave Grips Adjustable Joystick - Black is listed on Amazon. Price, availability, shipping and returns are set by Amazon and its sellers — check the listing for current terms. SpecPicks earns a small commission on qualifying purchases — thank you for supporting independent review work.

Check price on Amazon →

Related Controllers & Gamepads

Keep exploring SpecPicks

Other buying guides

Browse the catalog

Editorial

More guides & deep dives from the SpecPicks archive

Browse all articles & guides →

More reviews from the SpecPicks archive

Browse all reviews →

Earliest SpecPicks reviews

Browse full archive →
eXtremeRate ThumbsGear Interchangeable Ergonomic Thumbstick for PS5 Controller, for PS4 All Model Controller - 3 Height Domed and Concave Grips Adjustable Joystick - Black
View on Amazon →